ST106 Foundations of Horror Research
From topic to question
Booth's method: topic, question, problem, and why "Swamp Thing and the Gothic" is not yet a question.
Reading for this lesson
-
Required The Craft of Research Wayne C. Booth, Gregory G. Colomb, Joseph M. Williams, Joseph Bizup and William T. FitzGerald Part I and chapters 3 and 4
The core of the method.
-
To see how comics scholars frame questions.
Introduction
"I want to write about Swamp Thing and the Gothic" is a topic. It cannot be answered because it does not ask anything. The Craft of Research describes the move from topic to question to problem: narrowing until you have something specific enough to answer, and then asking why the answer matters to anyone but you[1]. This lesson practises that move on Year One material.
Learning objectives
- Distinguish topic, question and problem.
- Narrow a question until it can be answered with evidence.
- Explain why a question matters in terms a reader would accept.
Key concepts
Topic, question, problem
Booth's sequence: a topic is an area; a question is something you do not know about it; a problem is what would be lost if the question were not answered[1]. "Wrightson's inking" is a topic. "How does Wrightson's line distinguish the creature's body from human bodies in Swamp Thing #1?" is a question. The problem is what the answer tells us about how comics make monsters.
Narrowing
Add conditions until the question can be answered from evidence you can actually reach. Which issues, which pages, which concept, which comparison. Stop when the question is small enough to answer and large enough to matter.
The so-what
Every question needs a reader who cares. Practise writing the sentence "This matters because..." and cutting it if the ending is weak.
Questions to think about while reading
- Which of Booth's examples are closest to humanities work, and which are far from it?
- What does he say about questions that are too big? Too small?
- How does the Guidebook's introduction describe the questions comics studies asks?
Things to notice
- The difference between a question you can answer by reading and one that needs archives or interviews.
- Questions that hide an answer ("Isn't Wrightson better than Redondo?").
- Questions that are really two.
Reflection questions
- Which Year One assignment question did you find hardest, and was the difficulty in the question or in you?
- If you could ask one question of Len Wein, what would it be? Could you answer it from the comics instead?
Homework and tasks
Write three research questions from Year One material, each narrowed in Booth's way, each with a "this matters because" sentence. Pick the best; it may become Assignment 2.
Next lesson
Next week: finding sources and judging them, including the two hardest cases, the fan site and the open-access thesis.
References
- Wayne C. Booth, Gregory G. Colomb, Joseph M. Williams, Joseph Bizup and William T. FitzGerald. The Craft of Research. University of Chicago Press, 2016 (fourth edition).
Want to tick off the reading, keep notes and do the homework? Sign in or join. Reading stays free either way.