ST106 Foundations of Horror Research
Finding and judging sources
Where academic work lives, how to reach it without a university login, and how to tell what a source is worth.
Reading for this lesson
-
Required The Craft of Research Wayne C. Booth, Gregory G. Colomb, Joseph M. Williams, Joseph Bizup and William T. FitzGerald chapters 5 and 6
On finding and engaging sources.
-
Required Green smile, interrupted: the frustrated ecological possibilities in Alan Moore's Swamp Thing University of British Columbia thesis (author as listed in the repository) the abstract and the first chapter
A worked example of an open-access thesis.
-
To learn the interface.
Introduction
Most academic writing sits behind subscriptions, but far more is reachable than people think. Open-access journals, university repositories, publishers' free chapters, library catalogues that show you what exists even when they cannot show you the text, and public libraries that can order almost anything. This lesson is about reaching sources and, once reached, judging them.
The worked example is an open-access thesis on Moore's Swamp Thing held in a university repository[1]. It is free, it is long, it is examined but not peer reviewed, and it cites everything. Learning what to do with it teaches most of the skill.
Learning objectives
- Use catalogues, repositories and directories to locate sources.
- Judge a source by publisher, review process, date, evidence and use.
- Extract a reading list from a source's own references.
Key concepts
Where to look
Library catalogues (your public library, and any university catalogue, which are open to search). Google Scholar for articles and citations. Directories of open-access journals. University repositories for theses. Publishers' pages for tables of contents and sample chapters. The Grand Comics Database for comics facts[2]. Each has a different reach; know which to use for what.
Credibility
Booth's questions apply: who wrote it, who published it, was it reviewed, when, on what evidence, and how is it used by others[3]. A peer-reviewed article from a university press is not automatically right; a fan site is not automatically wrong. But the burden of checking differs. Learn to say "this is a fan site, and I have checked its claim against the comic" rather than citing the site as if it were the comic.
Reading a bibliography
The fastest way to find the literature is to find one good source and read its references. The thesis in this week's reading has a bibliography that would take a year to exhaust. Mine it.
Questions to think about while reading
- Who examined the thesis, and what does that tell you about its standing?
- Which of its sources are books from university presses, which are articles, which are comics?
- Is there anything in it you could check against a comic you own?
Things to notice
- Dates. A 2010 source on comics scholarship predates most of the field's growth. Note when things were written.
- Self-citation and community: comics scholars cite each other. Map who cites whom in the thesis.
- What the GCD does not tell you: it records what a comic is, not what it means.
Reflection questions
- What is the best source you have found this week, and what makes it the best?
- Is a fan wiki worse than a badly argued academic article? How would you tell?
Homework and tasks
Find six sources on the question you chose last week: at least three academic, at least one primary, all located in a way you can repeat. Record for each where you found it and one sentence on its credibility. This is the raw material for Assignment 1.
Next lesson
Next week: reading academic writing without drowning, and notes that keep your words separate from theirs.
References
- University of British Columbia thesis (author as listed in the repository). Green smile, interrupted: the frustrated ecological possibilities in Alan Moore's Swamp Thing. University of British Columbia, cIRcle. Link Source requires verification
- Grand Comics Database contributors. Grand Comics Database. Link
- Wayne C. Booth, Gregory G. Colomb, Joseph M. Williams, Joseph Bizup and William T. FitzGerald. The Craft of Research. University of Chicago Press, 2016 (fourth edition).
Want to tick off the reading, keep notes and do the homework? Sign in or join. Reading stays free either way.