ST106 Foundations of Horror Research
Reading academic writing and taking notes
How to read an article or chapter for its argument, and how to record it so you never plagiarise by accident.
Reading for this lesson
-
Required Alan Moore and the Gothic Tradition Matthew J. A. Green (editor) the introduction and one chapter on Swamp Thing
The worked example of an academic collection.
-
Required The Craft of Research Wayne C. Booth, Gregory G. Colomb, Joseph M. Williams, Joseph Bizup and William T. FitzGerald chapter 6
On engaging sources and note-taking.
Introduction
Academic writing is built to be read strategically. An abstract tells you the claim; an introduction tells you the question and the plan; section headings tell you the structure; a conclusion tells you what the author thinks they proved. Reading every word in order is the slow way. This lesson teaches the fast way, and then the slower way that follows when a source turns out to matter.
The second half is notes. Every research note in your Green Book has fields for quotation, paraphrase and your own comment, and a page number, because the commonest form of accidental plagiarism is a paraphrase that drifted into a quotation without its marks. The tool enforces the separation. This lesson explains why.
Learning objectives
- Extract the claim, evidence and structure of an academic text quickly.
- Take notes that separate quotation, paraphrase and comment, with page numbers.
- Recognise the forms of accidental plagiarism and prevent them.
Key concepts
The strategic pass
Abstract, introduction, headings, conclusion, then the bibliography. Fifteen minutes per chapter. Decide: is this source central, useful or irrelevant to my question? Only central sources get the slow read.
The three fields
Quotation: the author's exact words, in quotation marks, with the page. Paraphrase: the author's idea in your words, with the page, and no quotation marks because there are none of their words in it. Comment: what you think, why it matters to your question, where you disagree. Never let the three mix in one sentence. Booth's chapter on engaging sources makes the same point with examples[1].
Reading an edited collection
Green's collection has fourteen chapters by different authors[2]. The editor's introduction frames them; each chapter has its own argument. Citing the collection is not citing a chapter. Learn the difference and record the chapter author, title and page range.
Questions to think about while reading
- What does the editor say the collection is for? Do the chapters agree?
- In the Swamp Thing chapter you chose, what is the claim in one sentence, and what is the best piece of evidence?
- Where does the chapter cite Moore's comics, and how (issue, page, collected edition)?
Things to notice
- Signposting. Academic writers tell you what they are about to do. Use the signposts.
- Footnotes. Sometimes the argument's most interesting part is in a note.
- Your own comments. Are they questions, agreements or objections? A good note has all three over time.
Reflection questions
- How long did the strategic pass take, and what did it miss?
- Have you ever plagiarised by accident? How would you know?
Homework and tasks
Make research notes on three of your six sources using the Green Book tool: at least two quotations, two paraphrases and two comments each, every one with a page.
Next lesson
Next week: referencing. MHRA style, the special case of comics, and why the reference list is part of the argument.
References
- Wayne C. Booth, Gregory G. Colomb, Joseph M. Williams, Joseph Bizup and William T. FitzGerald. The Craft of Research. University of Chicago Press, 2016 (fourth edition).
- Matthew J. A. Green (editor). Alan Moore and the Gothic Tradition. Manchester University Press, 2013.
Want to tick off the reading, keep notes and do the homework? Sign in or join. Reading stays free either way.