ST301 After Moore: Forty Years of Swamp Thing
The present, and the essay
The creator's return, a new avatar, a Black Label hell, and the question of whether Swamp Thing is a character or a run.
Reading for this lesson
-
Required The Swamp Thing, Volumes 1 and 2: Becoming and Conduit Ram V (writer), Mike Perkins (art) volume 1, Becoming
-
Optional Swamp Thing Winter Special #1 Tom King (writer) and Jason Fabok (art); with Len Wein's final Swamp Thing script the whole issue
Wein's last script.
Introduction
Three recent answers. In 2016 Len Wein, who created the character in 1971, returned to write him for six issues with Kelley Jones[1]; the 2018 Winter Special paired a Tom King and Jason Fabok story with the last script Wein wrote before his death[2]. In 2021 Ram V and Mike Perkins gave the Green a new avatar, Levi Kamei, an Indian American whose origin runs through Kaziranga in India, across sixteen issues and two Future State issues[3]. Jeff Lemire and Doug Mahnke's Green Hell, at DC Black Label, returned to the original creature in a short, brutal series[4].
The three are the module's final evidence. Wein's return asks whether a creator can reclaim a character remade by someone else. Ram V's asks whether the avatar can be someone other than Holland at all, and whether the swamp can be in Assam. Lemire's asks what is left when you strip the mythology back to a monster in a swamp. This last lesson reads them, and then turns to the essay: is Swamp Thing a character, or a run?
Learning objectives
- Analyse the creator's return and what it claims about ownership.
- Read Ram V's Levi Kamei as the most consequential change to the premise since Moore.
- Argue a position on whether the character survives its defining author.
Key concepts
The creator's claim
Wein wrote the creature first and, forty-five years later, last. Ask what his 2016 series takes from Moore and what it refuses, and whether the creator's version is the true one or one among many.
A different man
Levi Kamei is not Alec Holland, not white, not American-born, and his swamp is partly Indian. Ram V's run tests whether the mythology (the Green, the avatar, the Parliament) is bigger than the man Moore wrote it around. Read "Becoming" for what it keeps, and ask whether the character is a role.
Character or run
Everything in this module is evidence. A character survives its author if later writers can make it mean something new without losing what made it worth continuing. A run does not survive; it is reread. Decide which Swamp Thing is, and make the decision from the evidence of forty years.
Questions to think about while reading
- What does Wein's 2016 series do with Moore's mythology?
- How does Ram V handle the Parliament of Trees, if at all?
- What does Green Hell keep of anything after 1971?
Things to notice
- Kelley Jones's art. The horror comic look of the 1990s, on a 2016 book.
- Perkins's swamp. Is it the same swamp?
- Black Label. The prestige imprint as the successor of Vertigo, itself the successor of Moore's run.
Reflection questions
- Who owns a character: the creator, the definer, the publisher, or the readers?
- Has this survey made you value Moore's run more or less?
Homework and tasks
Draft the plan of Assignment 2: your answer to "character or run", the five runs you will use as evidence, the scholarship and the creator accounts you will cite, and the counter-argument you will meet.
Next lesson
This is the last lesson of ST301. Both assignments are open. ST302 follows: the wider DC horror line, from Cain and Abel to Vertigo.
References
- Len Wein (writer), Kelley Jones (art). Swamp Thing: The Dead Don't Sleep. DC Comics, 2016.
- Tom King (writer) and Jason Fabok (art); with Len Wein's final Swamp Thing script. Swamp Thing Winter Special #1. DC Comics, 2018.
- Ram V (writer), Mike Perkins (art). The Swamp Thing, Volumes 1 and 2: Becoming and Conduit. DC Comics, 2021 to 2022.
- Jeff Lemire (writer), Doug Mahnke (art). Swamp Thing: Green Hell. DC Black Label.
Want to tick off the reading, keep notes and do the homework? Sign in or join. Reading stays free either way.