ST301 After Moore: Forty Years of Swamp Thing
Snyder and Soule: the New 52
Alec Holland alive again, the Rot, the Rotworld crossover, and a run that ended by talking about endings.
Reading for this lesson
-
Required Swamp Thing by Scott Snyder Deluxe Edition Scott Snyder (writer), Yanick Paquette and others (art) "Raise Them Bones", #1 to #7
-
Required Swamp Thing Vol. 4: Seeder and the rest of Charles Soule's run Charles Soule (writer), Kano, Jesus Saiz and others (art) "Seeder", #19 to #23, and #40
The opening and the ending.
Introduction
DC relaunched its whole line in 2011, and Scott Snyder and Yanick Paquette's Swamp Thing began with Alec Holland alive, human, and refusing the Green that wanted him back[1]. "Raise Them Bones" (#1 to #7) is a superhero origin told as horror: the Rot, the force of decay, has its own avatar, and Abby Arcane is bound to it. The Rotworld crossover with Animal Man (#12 to #18) made the Green, the Red and the Rot into a cosmology on the scale of Millar's Parliaments. Charles Soule wrote #19 to #40: "Seeder" introduced Capucine and revealed Woodrue behind a series of gifts to the world; the final arc brought a Machine Queen, an Avatar of the Grey and Arcane; and #40, the last issue, is a comic about how comics end[2].
The New 52 run reversed Moore's central move: it gave the creature Alec Holland back. This lesson asks what that decision cost and what it bought, and reads Soule's ending as the most self-aware page in the character's history.
Learning objectives
- Analyse Snyder's restoration of Alec Holland as a reading of Moore.
- Assess the Green, Red and Rot cosmology against Moore's Green and Millar's Parliaments.
- Read Soule's #40 as a commentary on the character's serial life.
Key concepts
Holland alive
Moore's run began by killing the idea that the creature was Alec Holland. Snyder's began by bringing Holland back and making him choose. Ask whether that is a betrayal, a homage, or a different story that happens to use the name.
Three colours
Green, Red, Rot. The New 52 cosmology is a colour wheel. Ask what it gains in clarity and loses in strangeness, and compare with Moore's Green, which had no opposite until the Darkness.
Endings
Soule's #40 stages the creature reviving the former avatars of the Green to fight, and turns the fight into a reflection on what an ending is for a character who cannot end. Read it beside Moore's #64 and Millar's #171. Three endings, three theories.
Questions to think about while reading
- How does Snyder draw on the 1971 origin and on Moore, and where does he depart?
- What is Capucine, and what does Soule use her for?
- What does #40 say about endings, in its own words?
Things to notice
- Paquette's layouts. Vines as panel borders. The page as plant.
- The crossover machinery. How much of the run is required reading for something else.
- Soule's Woodrue. The third major version of the character in the course.
Reflection questions
- Was giving the creature Alec Holland back a mistake?
- What is the best ending the character has had?
Homework and tasks
Write three hundred words on #40 beside #64 and #171: three endings, what each believes an ending is, and which is the truest to the character.
Next lesson
Last week: Wein's return, Ram V's Levi Kamei, Lemire's Green Hell, and the essay.
References
- Scott Snyder (writer), Yanick Paquette and others (art). Swamp Thing by Scott Snyder Deluxe Edition. DC Comics.
- Charles Soule (writer), Kano, Jesus Saiz and others (art). Swamp Thing Vol. 4: Seeder and the rest of Charles Soule's run. DC Comics.
Want to tick off the reading, keep notes and do the homework? Sign in or join. Reading stays free either way.