ST301 After Moore: Forty Years of Swamp Thing

Vaughan, Diggle and Dysart: the 2000s

Tefé as protagonist, the creature without his human template, and a run that returned to the swamp.

About 150 minutes. Free to read. You only need an account to keep notes and submit assignments.

Reading for this lesson

Introduction

Three attempts in six years. Brian K. Vaughan's 2000 series, twenty issues, made Tefé Holland the protagonist: a teenager with a plant elemental's power and a human's temper, drawn by Roger Petersen and others[1]. Andy Diggle and Enrique Breccia's 2004 relaunch, "Bad Seed", freed the creature from Alec Holland's human template and made him a threat to be stopped by Constantine[2]. Joshua Dysart took over the same series and brought it back to Louisiana, ecology and the Cajun south[3].

The three are three readings of what the character is for. Vaughan: the story is the next generation. Diggle: the story is what happens when the human is removed. Dysart: the story is the place. This lesson reads each opening and asks which reading of Moore each is.

What you are studying

Three relaunches as three theories of the character.

Learning objectives

  • Analyse Vaughan's Tefé series as a generational reading of the mythology.
  • Assess Diggle's removal of the human template as a thought experiment.
  • Read Dysart's return to place as a reaction against both.

Key concepts

The next generation

Vaughan's series asks whether the mythology can be inherited by a character who is not the creature. Ask what Tefé keeps of her parents and what the series does with the swamp when its centre is a teenage girl.

Without the human

Diggle's premise is the Anatomy Lesson pushed to its end: if the creature is a plant that thought it was a man, what is it when it stops thinking so? Ask whether "Bad Seed" answers the question or only stages the threat, and what Constantine's presence says about who is allowed to answer.

Back to the swamp

Dysart's run is the one of the three that most resembles Moore's method: a place, an ecology, a horror drawn from the local. Ask whether resemblance is fidelity, and whether fidelity was what the character needed by 2005.

Questions to think about while reading

  • What is Tefé's relationship to the Green, and how is it different from her father's?
  • In "Bad Seed", what does the creature do that Moore's never would, and why?
  • What is the ecological threat in "Healing the Breach"?

Things to notice

  • Breccia's art. An Argentine master of black ink on a DC horror book.
  • Cover design across the three series. How the character was sold in each decade.
  • The absence of Abby, or her presence. Where she is in each.

Reflection questions

  • Which of the three would you have continued?
  • Is a relaunch a reading or an erasure?

Homework and tasks

Write three hundred words comparing the opening issues of Vaughan's and Diggle's series as readings of Moore: what each takes as the character's essence, and what each throws away.

Next lesson

Next week: the New 52. Snyder and Soule.

References

  1. Brian K. Vaughan (writer), Roger Petersen and others (art). Swamp Thing by Brian K. Vaughan, Volumes 1 and 2. DC Comics.
  2. Andy Diggle (writer), Enrique Breccia (art). Swamp Thing Book 1: Bad Seed. DC Comics, 2004.
  3. Joshua Dysart (writer), Enrique Breccia, Timothy Green, Richard Corben and others (art). Swamp Thing (2004 to 2006), Joshua Dysart's issues. DC Comics.

Want to tick off the reading, keep notes and do the homework? Sign in or join. Reading stays free either way.