ST305 Independent Specialism
From interest to question
Booth's three steps, applied to your own curiosity about the field.
Reading for this lesson
-
Required The Craft of Research Wayne C. Booth, Gregory G. Colomb, Joseph M. Williams, Joseph Bizup and William T. FitzGerald part one: from topics to questions to problems
-
Recommended The Undergraduate Research Handbook Gina Wisker the chapters on choosing and defining a project
Introduction
Booth, Colomb and Williams describe research as three moves: from a topic (a thing you are interested in) to a question (something you want to know about it) to a problem (why the answer matters to anyone but you)[1]. Most failed projects stop at the first move. "Abby Arcane" is a topic. "How has Abby Arcane been written by writers after Moore?" is a question. "Whether Abby survives as a character or becomes a function of the creature's story tells us whether the run's love story was ever hers" is a problem.
This workshop takes you through the three moves with your own interest. It also sets the scope: 4,000 words is about four times a Year Two essay and a quarter of the dissertation. It can hold one question and one argument, developed properly. It cannot hold a survey.
Learning objectives
- Distinguish topic, question and problem.
- Draft three candidate questions and choose one.
- Define a scope that 4,000 words can hold.
Key concepts
The three moves
Take each of your three interests through Booth's moves. Where a move fails (you cannot say why the answer matters), that is information: the interest may be real but the project is not there yet.
Scope
A question with a defined set of texts, a defined period and a defined method is a project. "Abby after Moore" needs a set of runs (choose three), a period (1987 to 2015), a method (close reading of her scenes). Without those, it is a mood.
The so-what test
Booth's problem is answered by finishing the sentence "and this matters because". If the sentence ends with "it is interesting", start again. If it ends with something about how comics work, how horror works, or how a character survives, you have a project.
Questions to think about while reading
- What does Booth mean by a "practical" versus a "conceptual" problem, and which is yours?
- What do the examples in Booth have that your candidates lack?
- Which of your three interests already has sources you have seen?
Things to notice
- Your own Green Book. Two years of entries. The project is probably already in it.
- The course's gaps. What the modules skipped is a list of projects.
- The word "explore". If your question uses it, it is not yet a question.
Reflection questions
- Which of your interests frightens you a little? That may be the one.
- What would you do with this project if there were no assignment?
Homework and tasks
Write your three candidate questions, each with topic, question, problem and scope, and one paragraph choosing among them.
Next lesson
Workshop 2: finding and judging sources, and building the annotated bibliography.
References
- Wayne C. Booth, Gregory G. Colomb, Joseph M. Williams, Joseph Bizup and William T. FitzGerald. The Craft of Research. University of Chicago Press, 2016 (fourth edition).
Want to tick off the reading, keep notes and do the homework? Sign in or join. Reading stays free either way.