ST305 Independent Specialism

Finding and judging sources

Where comics scholarship lives, how to read a bibliography as a map, and how to write an annotation that is useful.

About 180 minutes. Free to read. You only need an account to keep notes and submit assignments.

Reading for this lesson

Introduction

Comics scholarship lives in a few journals (ImageTexT, the Journal of Graphic Novels and Comics, Studies in Comics, Inks), in university-press monographs, in edited collections, and in a great deal of online writing of variable quality. Horror studies lives beside it. Eco's advice, written for a world of card catalogues, still holds: a bibliography is built by following citations from one good source to the next, and each source gets a card that records where it is, what it says and what you think of it[1].

This workshop teaches the search and the judgement. The exercise is Beineke's open-access article[2]: read it, take its bibliography, follow three citations to their sources, and judge each. Then do the same with Round's monograph[3]. By the end you should have the beginnings of your own bibliography and know how to grow it.

What you are studying

The literature search as a craft, and source evaluation as a habit.

Learning objectives

  • Locate scholarship in comics and horror studies.
  • Follow citations to build a bibliography.
  • Evaluate a source's credibility and write a useful annotation.

Key concepts

Following the chain

Every scholarly source cites others. Start from one good one and follow. Beineke's bibliography will lead you to Moore criticism, Green Man scholarship and ecocriticism; Round's will lead you to Gothic theory and comics studies. Record where each step took you.

Judging

For each source ask: who wrote it, for whom, with what review, when, and does it cite its own sources? A university-press book, a peer-reviewed article, a trade-press report, a fan blog and a publisher's marketing page are five different kinds of evidence. Use all five if you need to, and say which is which.

The annotation

An annotation is three sentences: what the source argues, what evidence it uses, and what it is good for in your project. A fourth if it has a weakness. It is not a summary and not a review. Eco's card is the model[1].

Questions to think about while reading

  • Which of Beineke's sources are peer reviewed, and how do you know?
  • What does Round's bibliography contain that this course's reading lists do not?
  • Where would you look for scholarship on your own question that these two do not reach?

Things to notice

  • Open access. Which sources anyone can read for free. Your project should lean on them where it can.
  • The Grand Comics Database. Every publication fact in your bibliography checked there.
  • The sources marked "requires verification" across this degree. Verifying one is a good afternoon's work and a lesson in itself.

Reflection questions

  • What is the oldest source your chain reached, and the newest?
  • Which source changed your question?

Homework and tasks

Draft Assignment 1: your proposal (question, problem, scope, method) and an annotated bibliography of at least eight sources you have seen.

Next lesson

Workshop 3: methods for the study of comics.

References

  1. Umberto Eco, translated by Caterina Mongiat Farina and Geoff Farina. How to Write a Thesis. MIT Press, 2015 (Italian original 1977).
  2. Colin Beineke. "Her Guardiner": Alan Moore's Swamp Thing as the Green Man. ImageTexT: Interdisciplinary Comics Studies, vol. 5, #4. 2010. Link
  3. Julia Round. Gothic in Comics and Graphic Novels: A Critical Approach. McFarland, 2014.

Want to tick off the reading, keep notes and do the homework? Sign in or join. Reading stays free either way.