ST305 Independent Specialism
Revising and reflecting
Reading your own draft as a stranger, cutting, checking, and writing the reflection that closes the module.
Reading for this lesson
-
Required The Craft of Research Wayne C. Booth, Gregory G. Colomb, Joseph M. Williams, Joseph Bizup and William T. FitzGerald the chapters on revising
-
Recommended The Undergraduate Research Handbook Gina Wisker the chapter on writing up and presenting
Introduction
Revision is not proofreading. It is reading the draft as a stranger who has your question and none of your memory, and asking at every paragraph: what does this claim, what is the evidence, and does the one follow from the other[1]? Most drafts have a paragraph that does not know what it claims, a claim that has no evidence, and evidence that is doing nothing. Revision finds all three.
This workshop gives you a procedure and a checklist, and asks for the reflection that the platform records with every submission: what you learned, what you would do differently, and what this study has taught you about the dissertation to come.
Learning objectives
- Revise a long draft structurally, then locally.
- Check every citation and every fact against the verification log.
- Write a reflection that is useful for the next project.
Key concepts
Structural first
Before any sentence is fixed, check the structure: does the introduction promise what the conclusion delivers? Do the argument sentences still make the argument? Is the objection section honest? Move or cut sections before touching prose.
Then local
Paragraph by paragraph: one claim, its evidence, a connection. Sentence by sentence: cut what restates, split what joins two ideas, replace what is vague. Then the checks: every citation findable, every publication fact dated in the Green Book, no image reproduced, no source unseen.
The reflection
The platform asks for a reflection with each submission. Make it real: what the study found that you did not expect, what method failed, what you would need for a longer version. This reflection is the first page of your dissertation planning.
Questions to think about while reading
- What does Booth say to cut first?
- Which of your paragraphs has no argument sentence?
- What does your draft assume the reader knows that they might not?
Things to notice
- Length. If you are over, cut summary, not evidence. If you are under, you are missing evidence, not words.
- Em dashes. This degree does not use them. Check.
- The rubric. Read it once more before submission and mark where each criterion is met.
Reflection questions
- What did the study teach you that no module did?
- What would you research next?
Homework and tasks
Revise, check and submit Assignment 2 with its reflection. Then rest.
Next lesson
This is the last workshop of ST305. ST306, the dissertation, follows, and begins where your reflection ends.
References
- Wayne C. Booth, Gregory G. Colomb, Joseph M. Williams, Joseph Bizup and William T. FitzGerald. The Craft of Research. University of Chicago Press, 2016 (fourth edition).
Want to tick off the reading, keep notes and do the homework? Sign in or join. Reading stays free either way.