ST305 Independent Specialism
Drafting the study
Structure, the argument sentence, the paragraph as unit, and how to write four thousand words without padding.
Reading for this lesson
-
Required The Craft of Research Wayne C. Booth, Gregory G. Colomb, Joseph M. Williams, Joseph Bizup and William T. FitzGerald part four: planning, drafting and revising
-
Required "They Say / I Say": The Moves That Matter in Academic Writing Gerald Graff and Cathy Birkenstein the chapters on "they say" and "I say"
Entering the conversation.
Introduction
Four thousand words is one argument in four or five movements. Booth's model is the claim, the reasons, the evidence, the acknowledgement of alternatives, and the warrants that connect them[1]. Graff and Birkenstein's is the conversation: what others have said ("they say"), what you say back ("I say"), and why it matters[2]. Together they give you a structure: an introduction that states the question and the claim; a section that sets out what the field says; sections that make the argument from evidence; a section that meets the strongest objection; a conclusion that says what has changed.
This workshop drafts. It also warns: the commonest failure at this length is a first half that summarises and a second half that hurries. Plan the evidence by section before writing a word, and write the argument sentence for each section first.
Learning objectives
- Plan a 4,000-word structure with an argument sentence per section.
- Draft sections from evidence rather than summary.
- Use "they say / I say" moves to place your argument in the field.
Key concepts
The argument sentence
Every section has one sentence that says what it argues. Write them all before drafting. Read them in order: they should make the whole argument on their own. If they do not, the plan is wrong.
Evidence first
List the evidence for each section (pages, panels, documents, quotations) before writing the prose. Then the prose is the connection of evidence to claim, which is what argument is. Summary creeps in when evidence has not been chosen.
The conversation
Graff's templates are training wheels; use them in the draft and take them off in revision. The move that matters is naming what others have said accurately before saying what you say. In this field that often means naming a critic's reading of a page and then reading the page again.
Questions to think about while reading
- What does Booth say a draft's introduction should promise?
- Which "they say" moves fit your field, and which sound false in it?
- Where in your plan is the objection section, and what is the objection?
Things to notice
- Word budget. Introduction three hundred; field five hundred; argument two thousand five hundred across three sections; objection four hundred; conclusion three hundred. Adjust, but budget.
- Your own voice. Two years of reflections in the Green Book. It is in there.
- Padding. Every sentence that restates the previous one is a sentence stolen from the evidence.
Reflection questions
- What is the hardest section to draft, and why?
- Is your claim still the one you started with?
Homework and tasks
Write the full first draft of Assignment 2, from the section plan, with the evidence list beside you. Do not polish.
Next lesson
Workshop 6: revising, and the reflection.
References
- Wayne C. Booth, Gregory G. Colomb, Joseph M. Williams, Joseph Bizup and William T. FitzGerald. The Craft of Research. University of Chicago Press, 2016 (fourth edition).
- Gerald Graff and Cathy Birkenstein. "They Say / I Say": The Moves That Matter in Academic Writing. W. W. Norton, various editions (first 2006).
Want to tick off the reading, keep notes and do the homework? Sign in or join. Reading stays free either way.