ST306 Dissertation
The dissertation question
Eco's rules for a topic you can finish, and the proposal in outline.
Reading for this lesson
-
Required How to Write a Thesis Umberto Eco, translated by Caterina Mongiat Farina and Geoff Farina the chapter on choosing the topic
Eco's four rules.
-
Recommended The Undergraduate Research Handbook Gina Wisker the chapters on defining a research project
Introduction
Eco gives four rules for choosing a thesis topic: it should match your interests; the sources should be within reach; you should be able to handle the sources; and the method should be within your experience[1]. He adds a fifth in practice: it should be finishable. A dissertation on "the Gothic in comics" is not finishable. A dissertation on "how three writers after Moore handled Abby Arcane, and what that shows about whether a love interest can become a subject" is.
This workshop takes the question you reflected on at the end of ST305 (or a new one) through Eco's rules and Booth's three moves from ST305, and produces the proposal in outline: question, problem, scope, method, chapter sketch, sources within reach. It is the most important week of the module; a good question makes the rest labour, and a bad one makes it impossible.
Learning objectives
- Apply Eco's rules to candidate questions.
- Define scope, method and sources for a 10,000-word study.
- Produce a proposal outline with a chapter sketch.
Key concepts
Finishable
The question must be answerable from sources you can obtain in the time you have. List the primary texts (with editions) and the ten secondary sources you already know exist. If the list is short, the question is either too new (good, but risky) or too vague (start again).
Within your experience
Eco's fourth rule is humility. You have practised close reading, formal analysis, publication history, reception and comparison across two years. Choose a question those methods can answer. A dissertation is not the place to learn statistics.
The chapter sketch
Four or five chapters, each with an argument sentence, each advancing the claim. Write them now, badly. They will change; having them makes the changes visible.
Questions to think about while reading
- Which of Eco's rules does your candidate question fail, if any?
- What is the smallest version of your question that would still matter?
- What is out of reach, and can the question be designed around it?
Things to notice
- Your Green Book. Three years of entries. Search it for the question you keep returning to.
- The course's marked gaps: sources requiring verification, questions the modules left open. Each is a project.
- Time. Eco says a thesis takes between six months and three years. Plan for the former and forgive yourself the latter.
Reflection questions
- Why this question, and why you?
- What would it mean to be wrong?
Homework and tasks
Write the proposal outline: question, problem, scope, method, chapter sketch, primary texts with editions, ten secondary sources within reach. About eight hundred words.
Next lesson
Workshop 2: the literature review.
References
- Umberto Eco, translated by Caterina Mongiat Farina and Geoff Farina. How to Write a Thesis. MIT Press, 2015 (Italian original 1977).
Want to tick off the reading, keep notes and do the homework? Sign in or join. Reading stays free either way.