ST306 Dissertation

The literature review

What a review is for, how to organise it by argument rather than by author, and how to show the gap your dissertation fills.

About 180 minutes. Free to read. You only need an account to keep notes and submit assignments.

Reading for this lesson

Introduction

A literature review is not a list of what you have read. It is an argument about the field: what questions it has asked, what answers it has given, where those answers disagree, and where there is a gap your dissertation will fill[1]. It is organised by theme and argument, not by author and date. Graff and Birkenstein's rules for summarising and quoting are its ethics: represent each source's argument as its author would recognise it, then say what you make of it[2].

This workshop builds the review from the bibliography you began in ST305 and extended in Workshop 1. It ends with the gap stated in one sentence, which is the sentence the dissertation exists to fill.

What you are studying

The literature review as an argument about a field.

Learning objectives

  • Organise a body of scholarship by theme and disagreement.
  • Summarise and quote sources fairly and usefully.
  • State the gap the dissertation fills.

Key concepts

Themes, not authors

A review organised by author is a reading list with commentary. Organised by theme (the ecological readings; the Gothic readings; the readings of Abby; the publication histories) it becomes a map with blank areas. The blank areas are your gap.

Disagreement

Where two sources disagree is where the field is alive. Find every disagreement in your sources and state each fairly. Your dissertation will side with someone, or with no one; the review is where you show you understand the sides.

The gap

One sentence: "No one has yet asked X, although Y and Z make it possible to ask." If you cannot write it, the field may have already answered your question; find where, and revise the question.

Questions to think about while reading

  • What does Wisker say distinguishes a critical review from a descriptive one?
  • Which of your sources would object to how you have summarised them?
  • What is the gap?

Things to notice

  • Dates. A field's questions change by decade. Note when each source was written and what it could not have known.
  • Peer review. Which of your sources have it. The dissertation needs at least five that do.
  • Sources requiring verification. Verify or exclude before the review is drafted.

Reflection questions

  • Has reading the field changed your question?
  • Who in the field would you most like to argue with?

Homework and tasks

Draft the literature review, about 2,000 words, organised by theme, ending with the gap.

Next lesson

Workshop 3: chapter architecture, and Assignment 1.

References

  1. Gina Wisker. The Undergraduate Research Handbook. Palgrave Macmillan, 2018 (second edition).
  2. Gerald Graff and Cathy Birkenstein. "They Say / I Say": The Moves That Matter in Academic Writing. W. W. Norton, various editions (first 2006).

Want to tick off the reading, keep notes and do the homework? Sign in or join. Reading stays free either way.