ST305 Independent Specialism
Copyright, verification and citation
What you may reproduce, what you may claim, and how you show where it came from.
Reading for this lesson
-
Required MHRA Style Guide: A Handbook for Authors, Editors, and Writers of Theses Modern Humanities Research Association, edited by Chloe Paver the sections on citing books, articles, websites and comics
-
Required How to Write a Thesis Umberto Eco, translated by Caterina Mongiat Farina and Geoff Farina the chapter on intellectual honesty
Introduction
Three rules govern research in this degree and would govern it anywhere. Copyright: comics are copyrighted, and your study may quote and describe them but may not reproduce them; a panel description is evidence, a scanned page is a breach. Verification: nothing is cited that you have not seen, and nothing is asserted as fact that you have not checked in a source you can name; the course's own sources marked "requires verification" are the model of honesty about this. Citation: the MHRA style, with page numbers, so that any reader can find what you found[1].
Eco's chapter on intellectual honesty makes the case that these are not bureaucracy but the whole point[2]: a thesis is a claim that someone else could check. This workshop takes each rule in turn and applies it to your project.
Learning objectives
- Apply copyright rules to the use of comics in a written study.
- Practise verification as a habit and document it.
- Cite comics, books, articles, websites and films in MHRA style.
Key concepts
Describing, not reproducing
You may describe a panel in as much detail as you like. You may quote dialogue and captions briefly, with a citation. You may not include the image. Learn to describe an image so well that the reader does not need it; that is a skill, and ST104 taught it.
The seen and the heard
A source you have seen cited but not read is hearsay. If you must refer to it, say so: "cited in". If a fact matters, find its source. The Grand Comics Database, the publisher's own pages and the primary text itself are the three checks for any publication claim.
MHRA for comics
Comics citations need writer, artist, title, issue, publisher, date and page. The MHRA guide has a form; use it consistently. Films need director, year and, for a specific moment, a timestamp.
Questions to think about while reading
- What does the MHRA guide say about citing an issue of a comic, and a collected edition?
- What does Eco say the difference is between a footnote and a lie?
- Which items in your bibliography move from "seen cited" to "seen" this week?
Things to notice
- The course's own credibility notes. Each is a verification you can perform.
- Wikipedia. Useful for finding citations; never cited. Say why in one sentence.
- Your Green Book. It is your verification log. Date every check.
Reflection questions
- Has this degree changed how you treat a fact you read online?
- What is the difference between plagiarism and influence?
Homework and tasks
Convert your Assignment 1 bibliography to MHRA style with every publication fact checked and dated in your Green Book, and remove or mark anything you have not seen.
Next lesson
Workshop 5: drafting.
References
- Modern Humanities Research Association, edited by Chloe Paver. MHRA Style Guide: A Handbook for Authors, Editors, and Writers of Theses. Modern Humanities Research Association, 2024 (fourth edition). Link
- Umberto Eco, translated by Caterina Mongiat Farina and Geoff Farina. How to Write a Thesis. MIT Press, 2015 (Italian original 1977).
Want to tick off the reading, keep notes and do the homework? Sign in or join. Reading stays free either way.