ST305 Independent Specialism
Methods for studying comics
Close reading, formal analysis, publication history, reception, comparison: what each can answer and what each needs.
Reading for this lesson
-
Recommended The Craft of Research Wayne C. Booth, Gregory G. Colomb, Joseph M. Williams, Joseph Bizup and William T. FitzGerald part three: making a claim and supporting it
Evidence and warrants.
Introduction
A method is the way a question gets an answer. The degree has used five, mostly without naming them. Close reading (ST201, ST202) answers questions about what a text does. Formal analysis (ST104, ST206) answers questions about how a comic's form works. Publication history (ST103, ST302) answers questions about what was published, when, by whom and why. Reception (ST303, the Search Console of your own website if you have one) answers questions about what readers made of it. Comparison (ST301) answers questions about difference and change.
This workshop names them, says what each needs (which texts, which sources, which evidence), and asks you to choose and justify yours. Most projects need two: a primary method for the question and a supporting method for the context. Wisker's chapters on methodology are the frame[1]; Booth's account of claims, evidence and warrants is the test[2].
Learning objectives
- Describe five methods for the study of comics and horror.
- Match a method to a question and justify the match.
- Identify what evidence each method requires and where it lives.
Key concepts
Close reading and formal analysis
Both work on the page. Close reading asks what the page means; formal analysis asks how it makes meaning. Both need the primary text, in a specified edition (a recoloured collection is not the original issue; say which you used), and the ST104 vocabulary.
Publication history and reception
Both work on documents around the text. Publication history needs the Grand Comics Database, publisher records, creator interviews and, where you can get them, the original issues with their letters pages and adverts. Reception needs readers' words: letters pages, fanzines, reviews, sales figures where documented. Neither may be reconstructed from memory or invented.
Comparison
Comparison needs a principle: what is being compared, on what dimension, to answer what question. Without the principle it is two summaries side by side.
Questions to think about while reading
- What does Wisker say a methodology section should contain?
- What is a warrant, in Booth's sense, and what warrants do comics scholars rely on?
- Which method does your question need, and which supports it?
Things to notice
- Editions. Which edition of each primary text you will cite, and why.
- Evidence you cannot get. Sales figures, private correspondence, unpublished scripts. Name what is out of reach and design around it.
- Your own reading habits. The method you enjoy is not always the one the question needs.
Reflection questions
- Which method has this degree taught you best?
- Which would you like to learn?
Homework and tasks
Write your methods section: primary method, supporting method, evidence each needs, where it lives, what is out of reach, and why the pair fits your question. About five hundred words.
Next lesson
Workshop 4: the rules. Copyright, verification, citation.
References
- Gina Wisker. The Undergraduate Research Handbook. Palgrave Macmillan, 2018 (second edition).
- Wayne C. Booth, Gregory G. Colomb, Joseph M. Williams, Joseph Bizup and William T. FitzGerald. The Craft of Research. University of Chicago Press, 2016 (fourth edition).
Want to tick off the reading, keep notes and do the homework? Sign in or join. Reading stays free either way.